Skip to main content

Teresa Lawyer-Wisner

Not a lot about this case online. This post will likely be the most detailed on the case you will find.

                                                    (Literally the only picture I can find!)

Teresa Lawyer Wisner

Case Number: I90E1013 (Madison County Sheriffs Department) 
Reported: 10/2/91
Last Seen: 5/24/1990 Walking along Indiana State Rd. 37. Around 10:30 pm. Prior to that she was last seen at Roxie's Airport Inn in Elwood, Indiana.
Height: 5'1
Weight: 130lbs
Hair: Reddish Blonde/Brown
Eyes: Blue
Clothing: Last seen wearing a White and Gray Sweatsuit. Gold Purse with Gold Trim. Gold Chain with a Diamond Pendant. 
Spouse: Married James L. Wisner on 10/12/85. By all accounts it was a rocky relationship. They did have a 2 year old son at the time she disappeared. She was in the process of seeking a divorce and had an appointment with an attorney the following morning. (Interesting huh?)
Son: At the time she had a 2 year old son named Jimmy. James L. Wisner being the father. 
Parents: Walter ("Sonny") and Wilma Lawyer

Excerpts from the Herald Bulletin 4/16/91

"Earlier in in the investigation, Two Elwood men reported seeing a woman matching Teresa Wisner's description about 10:30pm on May 24th. She was walking along Indiana 37."

"They reported seeing a small gray car, Similar to the Toyota owned by the couple, Drive up alongside her. It appeared to be a man inside who exchanged words with her." (APD Detective Bob Blount stated)

"The man then shouted obscenities at the woman and drove away."

"Blount said the Elwood men later identified Wisner's Toyota as the car they had seen last May by the sound of the muffler."

 Herald Bulletin 4/20/91       

* Apparently Teresa voiced her dissatisfaction to her parents regarding her marriage prior to her disappearance.
* Wilma Lawyer said James Wisner talked to them about Teresa's behavior prior to May and asked her and Sonny to persuade Teresa to reconsider the decision to divorce him.

* Madison County Police Detective Bob Blount said he has talked with the Lawyers several times and suspects homicide after receiving a letter addressed to the couple. The letter reported Wisner's fear that she was in danger and named the source of her suspected danger.


*According to Detective Bob Blount a "Foul Oder was reported at Wisner's home 2 days after wife disappeared." And a Search Warrant was obtained on 4/21/91. 
* Brother in Law later found car abandoned. A 1979 Toyota.(Uh-Huh Sure!) 
* Wilma and Sonny later went through the legal system to obtain visitation rights for Jimmy.


Not a lot to go on with this case since there is so little online to find. Tried reaching out to her son Jimmy as well as his wife via Facebook. Never received a response. I do have contact info for her parents who are still in the area. I might reach out to them at some point. I agree its obviously a homicide. I doubt the mom would willingly just leave and never contact the son. The report of her walking down State Road 37 is very telling if we can believe that it was her. I believe it was. James L. Wisner's brother found the car and a search warrant was issued from the Anderson Police Department for James L. Wisner's residence. Its clear where the investigators were going with the investigation. And Detective Bob Blount stated he suspected homicide. No body and no other evidence shows why this investigation is cold. 


MissingPerson' Page
Madison County Sheriffs Department Facebook Post
Teresa L. Wisner Marriage Record
James L. Wisner Marriage Record
Herald Bulletin Article that briefly mentions Wisner
Airport Inn Facebook Page
Yelp Page for Airport Inn


Popular Posts

The Vanishing of Megan Renee Foglesong

Name:Megan Renee Foglesong
DOB: 1/20/1994
Missing: Late Nov/Early Dec of 2015 (Her last activity on Facebook was 11/30/2015)
Missing From: Alden, Kansas (Megan was formerly of Oneida, Illinois)
Height: 5'4 Weight: 150lbs (Fluctuates between 150-170lbs)
Hair: Sandy Blonde (Does occasionally die her hair) 
Eyes: Green (Has glasses and contact lenses)
Tattoos: Infinity Sign on Right Chest, Flower on Left Hip, Dream Catcher on Left Calf, Heart on Left Wrist that reads "Thick Thin".
Scars: Long Scar on Right Thigh. (Received 19 stitches as a kid)
Piercings: Ears, Tongue, and Belly Button.

“The last time I talked to her was the day before Thanksgiving,” said Megan’s stepmother, Dawn Foglesong

* Megan was from Oneida, Illinois but moved to Alden, Kansas.
* Megan's Biological Mother Pam Lewis lives in Kansas.
* Megan's stepmom Dawn Foglesong and her biological father Todd have led the way in the search for their daughter.
* Was at the time in a relationship with David Madden wh…

UPDATE: Dorothy Jane Scott

I've recently been in contact with Shawn Scott, Dorothy's son. He added some interesting things to my investigation of his mother's cold case. First off I was able to obtain a few pictures of Dorothy that he sent me. I wanted to see more than just the grainy newspaper pic we all have seen a thousand times. 

Also, Swinger's Psych Shop was a store that was previously owned by Dorothy's Father Jacob Scott. John Kycola purchased that store having already owned Custom John's Shop in Anaheim.

 Apparently there was a suspect that Shawn became aware of through several of Dorothy's friends who lived in Missouri. The suspects name was MIKE BUTLER. Apparently, Butler was an unstable individual who lived in the Santiago Mountains and was involved in cult activity. Which makes me think the dead dog that was discovered with her remains makes all the more sense now. Apparently he was obsessed with Dorothy. (Sound like our caller anyone?) His sister worked with Dorothy at Sw…

The Mind Boggling Murder of Dorothy Jane Scott

“To me, she exemplified the word, give. She’d just give and give and give, no matter what it cost her … she spent her last hours giving and being concerned about others.”  
Dorothy's Brother Jim at Dorothy's Funeral Service
* Dorothy Jane Scott * Date Of Birth-4/23/1948 * Son-Shanti Jacob Scott (Father being Dennis Terry of Fairgrove, MO) * Parents-Vera and Jacob Scott * Last Seen-Parking Lot of UCI Medical Center on 5/28/1980      around 11:30 pm.
* Killed- Most likely the night she disappeared. Or early            morning hours of the 29th. * Body Discovered- 8-6-1984

* Cause of Death- Undetermined
Dorothy Jane Scott was a 32 year old single mother living with her 4 year old son and Aunt in Stanton, California. She was described by friends and family as a kindhearted compassionate person. She was also described as religious and quiet. One friend described her as "Dull as a phone book" (Really?)  She is reported to have no interest in dating. She worked as a secretary at Swin…

The Murder of Joshua Wayne Crawford

On July 2, 2003, Joshua Wayne Crawford was found murdered in his Frederick apartment on his 21st birthday.....The crime remains unsolved.Authors Note- I have conversed at lengths with Joshua's mother Terry Scalera Horman. I cannot imagine how she must feel losing her son in the manner in which she did. This is a very solvable case. Even after all these years. I would first like to apologize to Terry for it taking so long for this post. It has been some time between posts mostly due to situations out of my control. I would like to point out Terri only discussed the basics of the case with me. Only the things that have been already covered in the media as she respects this is still an active investigation. Here we go.
Joshua Wayne Crawford

Date of Murder:July 2, 2003 at 6949 Exeter Court at Kingsbrook Apartments in Frederick MD.

Case Number: 03-104309 Frederick Police Department

* Crime was classified victim specific.
* At 12:41 p.m., deputies received a call about a person in cardiac…